Can you sue the government for damages? Here is how state liability works

sue the government for damages

Did you know that you can sue the government for damages caused by the irregular actions of an authority? In Mexico, there is a legal mechanism to do so: state tort liability (responsabilidad patrimonial del Estado). 

This procedure allows any individual or legal entity to claim compensation when a public institution causes them harm due to errors, omissions, or abuses in the performance of its duties.

What is state tort liability and what is it used for?

State tort liability is the right of private parties to be compensated for damages caused by an authority when it acts irregularly in providing a public service.

Key Features

  • It is strict and direct, meaning that it is not necessary to prove fault or intent on the part of the public official.

  • It is based on Article 113 of the Constitution, which establishes that the Federation, states, and municipalities must answer with their own assets for the acts or omissions of their authorities.

  • It is regulated by the Federal Law of State Tort Liability (Ley Federal de Responsabilidad Patrimonial del Estado) and by equivalent local laws.

  • It covers material, non-material (moral), or economic damages resulting from the abnormal operation of a public service.

What is it used for?

  • To obtain financial compensation for damages suffered.

  • To protect citizens against administrative abuses or errors.

  • To ensure accountability in the public sector.

When does a claim for state liability apply?

State liability does not apply in all cases. For it to proceed, certain legal requirements established by law must be met:

Requirement

Description

Irregular activity

The authority's actions must have been irregular or outside legal standards.

Verifiable damage

The damage must be real, quantifiable in monetary terms, and attributable to that action.

Causality link

There must be a direct link between the irregular act and the damage caused.

Timeliness

The claim must be filed within the legal statute of limitations (generally one year from the event).

Common Examples

  • An authority shuts down a business without legal cause and causes economic losses.

  • Poorly executed public works cause damage to private property.

  • A procedure or permit is denied without legal grounds.

Cases like these can lead to claims or even strategic administrative litigation, where the actions of federal or state authorities are scrutinized. You can read more about this approach in the article “Strategic litigation vs. federal authorities: what it is and when it is used”.

How is a claim for damages filed against the State?

The procedure for demanding state tort liability begins before the corresponding administrative authority and can escalate to the courts if there is no favorable response.

General Steps

  1. Identify the responsible authority. Determine whether the damage stems from a federal, state, or municipal agency.

  2. Gather evidence. Official records, photographs, expert opinions, and documents that prove the damage and its relationship to the public action.

  3. File the claim. Direct it to the agency that caused the damage or to the competent body (such as the Internal Control Body or the Ministry of Public Administration).

  4. Await resolution. The authority will evaluate whether compensation is warranted.

  5. Appeal if necessary. If the resolution is negative, an appeal can be filed before the Federal Court of Administrative Justice.

What types of damages can be claimed?

Type of Damage

Example

Actual damages (Damnum emergens)

Direct property damage, such as destruction of assets.

Lost profits (Lucrum cessans)

Loss of income that was not received.

Moral damage

Emotional distress or reputational harm.

Personal injury

Physical injuries resulting from an irregular act.

When is it advisable to sue the government for damages?

Suing the government for state tort liability is not always the fastest route, but it can be the most effective when:

  • The economic or non-material damage is significant and verifiable.

  • The authority acted without legal basis or exceeded its powers.

  • You have already exhausted internal remedies (for example, an administrative appeal) without a favorable outcome.

A real-world example occurs when an environmental authority such as PROFEPA closes a company without following proper legal procedure. In those cases, in addition to an administrative claim, specialized legal defense may be considered, as explained in “What to do if PROFEPA closes your company”.

What limitations does this procedure have?

Although the law protects citizens, in practice there are challenges:

  • Procedural deadlines are strict. If you do not act in time, you lose the right to claim.

  • The authority may argue grounds for exemption, such as force majeure or the victim's own fault.

  • The amount of compensation may depend on available public budgets.

  • It requires specialized legal counsel, as it is a technical and heavily documented process.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue the government without a lawyer?

It is possible to file the claim without a lawyer, but legal counsel is recommended to properly organize evidence and meet deadlines.

How much time do I have to file a claim?

Generally one year from the date the damage occurs or becomes known, although it may vary depending on the federal entity.

What happens if the authority denies my claim?

You can go before the Federal Court of Administrative Justice to challenge the ruling.

Can I claim moral damages, or only property damages?

Yes, the law allows for moral damages claims, provided they are provable and stem from an irregular action.

Is this the same as suing a public official?

No. In state tort liability, the State (the institution) is sued, not the individual public official personally.



Recommended Blogs

collective-appeal-for-constitutional-protection-in-administrative-matters

Knowing when and how multiple companies can litigate together in administrative matters is a strategic tool.

collective-appeal-for-constitutional-protection-in-administrative-matters

Knowing when and how multiple companies can litigate together in administrative matters is a strategic tool.

proportionality-principle-administrative-sanctions

Understanding how this principle works and how to invoke it can completely transform your defense strategy.

proportionality-principle-administrative-sanctions

Understanding how this principle works and how to invoke it can completely transform your defense strategy.

If you are looking for a reliable, efficient law firm with the capacity to protect your interests, contact us today for a consultation!


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

When is it advisable to initiate litigation against a state or federal authority?
How does an administrative litigation proceeding work in Mexico?
What types of companies need regulatory legal counsel?
What to do if the SAT freezes your company's bank accounts?
How to determine if a bidding process was unfair or contestable?
When is it advisable to initiate litigation against a state or federal authority?
How does an administrative litigation proceeding work in Mexico?
What types of companies need regulatory legal counsel?
What to do if the SAT freezes your company's bank accounts?
How to determine if a bidding process was unfair or contestable?
When is it advisable to initiate litigation against a state or federal authority?
How does an administrative litigation proceeding work in Mexico?
What types of companies need regulatory legal counsel?
What to do if the SAT freezes your company's bank accounts?
How to determine if a bidding process was unfair or contestable?